Bay Burger Menu Gallery
Burger
1/3 lb. of beef ground in-house, on a homemade bun, with your choice of: american, swiss, cheddar or blue cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle
Turkey Burger
a grilled white meat turkey patty with your choice of burger toppings and condiments
Fish Burger
atlantic cod, chopped and seasoned with garlic, shallots and parsley, breaded with panko and served with baby spinach, tomato, and our homemade tartar sauce
Veggie Burger
a black bean, roasted vegetable and brown rice patty with your choice of burger toppings and condiments
Grilled Cheese
cheddar and american cheese between thick slices of homemade bread
Hot Dog
all-beef kosher frank on a homemade bun
Falafel Sandwich
a patty made from ground chickpeas, garlic and fresh herbs, served on a homemade bun with tahini sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, and cucumber
Blt
crisp bacon, baby spinach, tomato and mayo on toasted homemade bread
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
crisp chicken tossed in spicy buffalo sauce topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and served on a homemade bun with blue cheese dressing on the side
Wedge Salad
a big wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with tomato, red onion, crumbled bacon and our homemade blue cheese dressing or tahini sauce
Side Salad
baby greens with cucumber, tomato, and carrot
Fries
Tots
Fries-n-tots
Crumbled Bacon And Melted Cheese (loaded)
Shakes
Despite its casual roadside vibe, the menu at Bay Burger in Sag Harbor offers a surprisingly well-rounded mix of comfort classics. The heart of the menu is its burger selection, starting with the straightforward Burger, and branching out to include options like the Turkey Burger, Fish Burger, and Veggie Burger, catering to a variety of preferences without overcomplicating the offerings. For something simpler but equally satisfying, the Grilled Cheese is a dependable go-to, appealing to both kids and nostalgic adults.
Sides play a crucial role in rounding out the experience. Guests can choose from Fries, Tots, or a mix with Fries-n-tots. But for those craving something more indulgent, the Crumbled Bacon and Melted Cheese (loaded) option transforms the standard side into a savory treat that complements any of the main items perfectly.
To wash it all down or satisfy a sweet tooth, Shakes are available and seem to be a staple of the Bay Burger experience-thick, classic, and sure to hit the spot. The menu’s strength lies in its simplicity and ability to deliver comfort food with quality ingredients in a casual setting. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, Bay Burger keeps it easy, tasty, and satisfying.